Development News and Information Sources
TERMS OF REFERENCE
External Evaluation:
An Enabling Environment for Fundamental Freedoms and Sustainable
Development in Asia, and its continuation, Enabling Community-Centred
Inclusive Development and Environmental Rights in Asia
1 November 2021 - 31 October 2027
I. Background and project context
The Asian Forum for Human Rights and Development (FORUM-ASIA) is one of the largest membership-based human rights organizations in Asia. Its strength lies with a network of more than 80 civil society member organizations across 23 countries in Asia. Founded in 1991, its work promotes and protects human rights through research, capacity strengthening and advocacy with member organizations, partners and affected communities across Asia.
FORUM-ASIA seeks an independent evaluation team or consulting firm to assess the project, An Enabling Environment for Fundamental Freedoms and Sustainable Development in Asia (1 November 2021 - 31 October 2024), and its continuation, Enabling Community-Centred Inclusive Development and Environmental Rights in Asia (1 November 2024 - 31 October 2027). The evaluation will examine the project’s achievements and its contribution to changes experienced by communities. The findings will inform decisions on the remaining implementation period and a possible follow-on project. The project and its continuation are supported by Brot für die Welt.
The project uses evidence-based research, capacity strengthening and advocacy to support marginalized communities, workers and human rights defenders to address human rights and environmental violations and participate in decisions affecting them.
The project implemented from November 2021 to October 2024 covered Mongolia, Myanmar, Pakistan, the Philippines, Sri Lanka and Kyrgyzstan. It built on separate earlier work on community issues around climate change, poverty and human rights in Indonesia and Nepal from 2019-2021. The 2021-2024 project aimed to create an enabling environment for fundamental freedoms and sustainable development in these six countries through evidence-based research, capacity building and advocacy.
Following the completion of the 2021-2024 project, the organization commissioned an end-of-project internal evaluation through the PME Programme to assess the project’s achievements, document lessons learned, and examine progress towards the objectives and outcomes of the project. The evaluation focused on the project’s relevance, effectiveness, outcomes and sustainability. While the assessment may have certain limitations in terms of its scope, process, and approaches and methodologies, it was guided by the OECD-DAC evaluation criteria and Brot für die Welt’s evaluation guideline to ensure a systematic and evidence-based assessment. The findings and lessons learned fed the current continuation phase (2024-2027).
Meanwhile, the continuation from November 2024 to October 2027 brings these eight country partnerships together (including Indonesia and Nepal) and adds Bangladesh and Thailand as new priority countries. It seeks increased acknowledgment and engagement by authorities, businesses, UN representatives, national human rights institutions and other stakeholders on human rights and environmental violations; increased participation of civil society and marginalized communities in decision-making; and stronger support and solidarity among communities and community-based defenders.
In Bangladesh, research examines labor rights in the ready-made garment sector, followed by capacity strengthening and advocacy. In Thailand, research examines the impacts of limestone mining on community rights and the environment, with follow-up support for affected communities. In the other eight countries, the continuation builds on earlier research and partner relationships through organizing, legal support, capacity strengthening and advocacy, according to country workplans.
At FORUM-ASIA, the Business and Human Rights Programme coordinates the project and works on research, publications, regional learning, capacity-strengthening and advocacy activities. National partners under the project implement country activities through partnership agreements, memoranda of understanding (MoUs) and workplans. The evaluation will assess these contributions and their connections, including how regional work supports country priorities.
II. Purpose and scope of the evaluation
The purpose of this evaluation is to assess progress toward the project objectives and outcomes, draw lessons from implementation and identify how FORUM-ASIA and its partners can better support communities in their pursuit of accountability. The assessment will consider communities’ priorities and strategies alongside opportunities to influence the policies and decisions of public authorities, businesses, financiers and other relevant stakeholders. It will identify factors that contributed to or hindered results and provide recommendations for the remaining implementation period and a possible follow-on project.
The evaluation covers all ten current country partnerships and relevant regional and international activities. All ten partners will be consulted directly, with a purposive sample of community participants and other stakeholders. Following initial consultations, which may take place online, the external evaluation team will identify cases for detailed analysis and any field visits.
The assessment of coherence will consider how the project connects to relevant parallel BHR work and FORUM-ASIA’s long-term strategic direction on business and human rights, the environment, climate and related work with environmental defenders. The findings and recommendations will inform the development of the BHR Programme, future projects and resource mobilization.
III. Evaluation framework and guiding questions
The evaluation framework will draw upon the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development’s Development Assistance Committee(OECD-DAC) criteria of relevance, coherence, effectiveness, efficiency, impact and sustainability. The evaluation will also track lessons learned and risks identified and mitigated, with attention to gender, inclusion, disability and environmental effects. The team will refine the questions and develop data collection instruments during inception.
|
Criterion |
Guiding questions |
|
Relevance |
|
|
Coherence |
|
|
Effectiveness |
|
|
Efficiency |
|
|
Impact |
|
|
Sustainability |
|
Across these questions, the evaluation should examine differences in access, participation, influence and benefits by gender, age, disability and other relevant forms of exclusion. It should assess environmental effects, civic space constraints and risks of reprisals, and how the project responded. The analysis should consider the range of project experiences, including barriers to progress, to explain differences in results and identify lessons for future work. These questions should also be able to explain how well the project aligns with FORUM-ASIA's Strategic Plan and Priorities.
IV. Evaluation approach and proposed methodology
To answer the guiding questions, the evaluation team will propose an appropriate approach and methods, to be further developed during the inception phase and approved by FORUM-ASIA and Brot für die Welt. The design is expected to provide credible evidence for the questions, meet the OECD-DAC Quality Standards for Development Evaluation and draw on Brot für die Welt’s public evaluation guidance.[1]
Limitations of the proposed approach and methods must be made explicit, including their consequences for the findings. The team will propose practical measures to address limitations and agree these in the inception report. The team is expected to follow a participatory, consultative and gender-sensitive approach, with close engagement with FORUM-ASIA, implementing partners and community participants.
a. Document review
FORUM-ASIA will provide available records and an initial document inventory. The review should include:
b. Consultation and analysis
The team may combine surveys, semi-structured interviews, focus group discussions, document analysis and other justified methods. The analysis is expected to use available quantitative monitoring and expenditure data alongside qualitative evidence and triangulate findings across sources. The inception report will explain how the proposed methods address the evaluation questions and identified evidence gaps.
Consultation will include all ten partners, sampled community participants and relevant FORUM-ASIA personnel. External actors able to corroborate outcomes may be consulted where feasible.
The assessment of selected outcome cases should trace the links between research, capacity strengthening, organizing, advocacy, institutional responses and community changes. Each case should identify the relevant period, actors, sequence of actions, strength of evidence and alternative explanations. The analysis should distinguish policy adoption from implementation and community benefit, and assess the contribution of the earlier project to the continuation.
c. Sampling and field visits
The technical proposal is expected to outline consultation coverage and a provisional approach to selecting outcome cases and any field visits, including how remote and in-person methods would be combined.
Selection will be informed by the evidence review and initial consultations, with attention to the need for community perspectives, geographical and thematic variation, accessibility, security, feasibility and cost. Any proposed visits should add evidence that cannot reasonably be obtained remotely and help inform decisions on sustainable support and a possible follow-on project.
The evaluation team will confirm the selection with FORUM-ASIA following initial consultations and review of the available evidence. The financial proposal will cover all proposed travel, accommodation, visas, insurance, local transport, interpretation and other delivery costs. Any changes will be subject to prior agreement within the contract and approved workplan.
d. Participation and confidentiality
The design is expected to protect participants’ safety and confidentiality throughout data collection and dissemination. Participation will be voluntary and based on informed consent, with confidential opportunities to speak and appropriate language support. The inception report will set out arrangements for anonymization, secure storage, restricted access, retention and deletion. Identifying material may be shared only with the relevant consent.
V. Coordination and proposed timetable
FORUM-ASIA will commission and contract the evaluation. The BHR Programme will lead coordination and partner liaison. The Planning, Monitoring and Evaluation Programme will provide technical and process support, including review of the evaluation framework. FORUM-ASIA will provide records, facilitate introductions and consolidate feedback. The evaluation team is responsible for the design, independent collection and analysis of evidence, quality control and delivery of outputs.
Brot für die Welt will review and approve the proposed evaluator selection, the inception report and the final evaluation report. The draft report will also be shared with Brot für die Welt for feedback.
The assignment is proposed for January-April 2027, with the final report submitted by 28 April 2027. The timetable and allocation of person-days below are indicative. An estimated 50 person-days are envisaged in total across the evaluation team. Following approval of the inception report, data collection, analysis and drafting may proceed concurrently.
Applicants may propose an integrated workplan that provides sufficient time for consultation, verification, analysis and revisions within the agreed budget and delivery deadlines.
|
Stage and activities |
Estimated days |
Proposed timing |
|
Inception: briefing, document review, evidence gaps, evaluation matrix, tools, stakeholder mapping and provisional sampling; inception report and revisions |
8 |
6 - 26 January 2027 |
|
Data collection: consultations across ten partnerships, selected outcome cases, agreed visits and preliminary case write-ups |
22 |
27 January - 19 March 2027 |
|
Analysis: triangulation, comparison across countries and implementation periods, and assessment against the evaluation criteria |
8 |
8 March - 2 April 2027 |
|
Presentation of findings and draft report: consolidation of case material, conclusions and recommendations into the integrated report |
6 |
22 March - 14 April 2027 |
|
Review and clarification: consolidated feedback and evidence queries |
2 |
15 - 21 April 2027 |
|
Revision, final report, presentation, response matrix and supporting materials |
4 |
22 - 28 April 2027 |
|
Total across all evaluators |
50 |
January - April 2027 |
VI. Evaluation deliverables
The team will submit the following in editable Word format and PDF. Outputs must answer the guiding questions and distinguish evidence, findings, conclusions and recommendations.
|
Deliverable |
Required content and proposed deadline |
|
Inception report |
Evaluation matrix linking questions, sources, methods and judgment criteria; refined theory of change; coverage of all ten partners; sampling criteria and provisional fieldwork options; tools; ethics; limitations; named team roles; person-days and workplan |
|
Evidence and outcome records |
Anonymized consultation and source records and a small, justified set of substantiated outcome cases, documenting coverage, limitations, contributions and alternative explanations. Each case will identify the relevant implementation period and project-supported activity |
|
Findings presentation and draft report |
Preliminary findings and implications, with appropriate partner and community feedback, and one integrated draft report with findings distinguishable for the 2021-2024 project and the 2024-2027 continuation |
|
Country and delivery assessment |
A concise, evidence-based assessment within the report and annexes of each of the ten partnerships, partner-led and FORUM-ASIA-led work, regional advocacy, subgrant support and complementary funding, with findings on needs, sustainable results and resource implications |
|
Final report |
Prioritized recommendations for the remaining implementation period and possible follow-on support, with responsible actors, timing and indicative resources; a response to consolidated comments; and the final presentation. |
|
Supporting materials |
Evaluation matrix and tools, source list, anonymized case records, recommendation matrix and a concise accessible summary for partners and communities; any translation or interpretation for agreed feedback will be specified and costed |
The integrated report should be 35-50 pages, excluding annexes, with an executive summary of 3-5 pages included in that length. It must contain the project background and context; purpose and scope; approach, methods and limitations; findings under all six criteria; period-specific and cumulative conclusions; lessons; and recommendations. Annexes should contain the ToR, workplan, evaluation matrix, tools, sources and anonymized consultation coverage. Identifying lists should be restricted where necessary.[2]
Multiple revisions may be needed before approval. The team must explain how quality control will be maintained throughout the assignment. Feedback may correct facts and test interpretations; unresolved differences should be recorded transparently. FORUM-ASIA will prepare its response and follow-up arrangements after receiving the evaluation.
VII. Independence and team requirements
Applications are invited from evaluation teams or consulting firms proposing at least two named evaluators. The team undertaking the assignment must represent at least two distinct nationalities. Preference will be given to teams including evaluators of Asian nationalities, alongside demonstrated experience and contextual knowledge relevant to the assignment.
Consulting firms must be based in Asia, in a country where FORUM-ASIA has a member organization. The firm must provide its legal registration details, the location of its Asian office and the names, CVs, roles and availability of all evaluators who will carry out the work. The same nationality and independence requirements apply to its proposed team. The membership directory is available at https://members.forum-asia.org/.
The evaluation must be external and independent. Any applicant or proposed evaluator with direct past or current involvement in the design, implementation, management, monitoring or delivery of the project or its continuation is ineligible. This includes involvement through FORUM-ASIA, an implementing partner or a project consultancy.
Include a brief signed declaration of any conflict of interest at the end of the technical proposal covering every proposed team member and the firm, where applicable. State any past or current project involvement and financial, professional or personal relationships that could affect impartiality, or expressly declare that none exist. Disclose emerging conflicts promptly. Please note that FORUM-ASIA will assess declarations prior to technical scoring, and direct project involvement disqualifies the affected application or proposed team as submitted.
The named team must undertake the work directly. Any specialist, interpreter or additional researcher must be disclosed, costed and subject to the confidentiality and independence requirements. Substitution of evaluators or subcontracting of substantive work requires prior written agreement. The lead evaluator remains responsible for quality and delivery.
VIII. Required qualifications
a. Lead evaluator
b. Team expertise
The team should collectively demonstrate experience in community advocacy and policy work; gender equality and social inclusion; human rights and environmental issues; and evaluation of partner-based or multi-country projects. Explain complementary skills, relevant country knowledge, language capacity and, as needed, the provision of interpretation. The lead must meet the lead qualifications and supporting evaluators should demonstrate relevant competence for their assigned tasks.
IX. Application package
The potential evaluation team or firm will submit a detailed technical and financial proposal. The application should include:
Payments will be linked to acceptance of deliverables. The proposed schedule is 30% following approval of the inception report, 30% following acceptance of the draft report and 40% following approval of the final report and supporting outputs. The agreed contract will confirm the payment terms and applicable tax treatment.
X. Assessment and selection
Applications will first be checked for completeness, the mandatory team and firm requirements, relevant qualifications, availability and independence. Eligible applications will then be assessed using the proposed technical criteria below. A minimum of 75 out of 100 technical points is required to proceed to financial assessment. Shortlisted applicants will be invited for an interview.
|
Technical criterion |
Maximum points |
|
Approach and methods, including community outcomes, contribution across the project and continuation, sampling, fieldwork and triangulation |
35 |
|
Lead evaluator’s qualifications and comparable evaluation experience |
20 |
|
Team experience with community advocacy, policy work and relevant BHR or environmental issues |
15 |
|
Asia experience, complementary country and language knowledge, and contextual understanding |
10 |
|
Feasible workplan, team allocation, participation arrangements and quality control |
10 |
|
Quality and relevance of submitted work samples |
10 |
|
Total technical score |
100 |
Final selection will consider the technical assessment, interview, proposed costs and overall value for the assignment. FORUM-ASIA may seek clarifications or negotiate the proposed scope and costs before an award. Selection is subject to satisfactory reference checks, available resources and Brot für die Welt’s approval.
XI. Submission of applications
Completed applications must be sent to applications@forum-asia.org by 27 November 2026, at 17:00 Bangkok time (UTC+7), with the subject “Inclusive Development and Environmental Rights Project Evaluation Consultancy”. Please note that late applications will not be considered, and only shortlisted applicants will be contacted.
Contact : applications@forum-asia.org